John Tummon (Republican Socialist Alliance) responds to Murdo Ritchie’s (RCN) Promoting Republicanism (http://republicancommunist.org/blog/2015/02/24/promoting-republicanism/)
Murdo Ritchie’s ‘Promoting Republicanism’ is a very important contribution to something we Republican Socialists need to keep working on until we have a theoretically rigorous and internally-tested critique of the poverty of any socialist analysis that fails to incorporate a full understanding of democracy and republicanism; only when this is in place can we think about breaking through to a position of genuine influence on the Left, let alone wider society outside of Scotland.
I see Murdo’s ‘Promoting Republicanism’ as a key stage in that development – and a very welcome one at that – and my comments, including my attempted development of aspects of what Murdo has written, are put forward in that spirit. What I increasingly find is that the most interesting left thinking in Britain comes from Republican Socialists, which was born out by the impressive quality of discussion at the recent RSA AGM in London; much of what passes as debate within the rest of the British (certainly the English) Left is stale repetition and, within Left Unity, the recycling of stale certainties from past eras in the name of ‘doing politics differently’. Unless we think politics differently, a failed practice will recur.
Continue reading “DEFINING REPUBLICANISM”
Tags: American Civil War, Antonio Gramsci, Atlantic Trade, Austro Hungarian empire, Author: John Tummon, Bank of England, Benedict Anderson, Black Rod, Bolsheviks, Cambridge College, Cheyenne, Chiapas, City of London, Clement Attlee, Cold War, communism, Corporation of the City of London, Crown Charters, Crown Dependencies, Crown-in-Parliament, Cuba, Dual Power, Duke of Westminster, East India Company, Edinburgh, European Union, Falklands War, Fascism, Ferdinand Braudel, First-Past-The -Post, Ford, Free Derry, Galbraith, Germany, Glasgow Media Group, Imagined Communities, Indian Mutiny 1858, ISIS Caliphate, Karl Marx, Kerensky, Kevin Cahill, Kronstadt Rising 1921, Krupp, Labour, Leon Trotsky, Manchester, Moghul India, Mozambique, Murdo Ritchie, National Socialism, Ottoman Empire, Paris Commune, Petrograd, Privy Council, public schools, Raymond Williams, Republican Socialism, Republican Socialist Alliance, Rosa Luxemburg, Russia, Russian National Assembly 1917, Safavid Persia, Siemens, Sioux, Social Democracy, social republic, Strangers Gallery, USA, Vienna Union 1921, Vladimir Lenin, Westminster, Woolsack, Zapatistas
