This article, written by Allan Armstrong (RCN) in 2015, has now been updated to include a new section 3 on Scotland. It has been moved from its earlier site.
Section A – The UK State and Britishness
Section B – From the Irish-British and ‘Ulster’-British ‘Insider’ to the Irish ‘Racialised’ and ‘Ethno-Religious Outsider’ to the new ‘National Outsider’
Section C – Britishness, the UK State, Unionism, Scotland and the ‘National Outsider’
A. THE UK STATE AND BRITISHNESS
Introduction
The purpose of this article is to examine the concept of the national outsider in relation to Britishness, for the people of Ireland, Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales. This has been done through the further development of the concept of the outsider used in Satnam Virdee’s significant book Racism, Class and the Racialised Outsider [1]. Here he outlines the creation of the racialised outsider [2]. Mary Davis’ earlier, but also significant, Comrade or Brother? A History of the British Labour Movement (3), wrote, in effect, about the gendered outsider, without using the term.
The first part of this article will look at the historically changing position of racialised and gendered outsiders in the UK before the second and third parts address the changing position of the national outsider. Here it will be shown how the post-war British Labour government provided widely accepted ‘insider’ Britishness status for those who held hybrid Scottish and Welsh and ‘Ulster’ British identities. This though excluded the Catholic Irish living in Northern Ireland, giving a continued basis for an Irish nationalist politics based on the Irish national outsider. For a brief period in the 1960s the development of the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Movement raised the possibility of widening the sectarian nationality-based ‘Ulster’-Britishness to create a new more inclusive Northern Ireland-Britishness, However, an alliance of the Ulster Unionism, Loyalism and the UK state thwarted this, leading to the re-emergence of a reinvigorated Irish republicanism, which drew support from those still treated as national outsiders by the UK state.
Furthermore, in the context of a continued imperial decline of the UK, the 1960s saw the existing Scottish-British and Welsh-British identities becoming more effectively challenged. This led to a prolonged attempt by the liberal wing of the British ruling class to try to democratise these identities within a political framework of Devolution. The failure of the Sunningdale Agreement in the face of reactionary unionism, and the 1979 Scottish and Welsh Devolution Bills through conservative unionist opposition, followed later by the lukewarm liberal unionist nature of the 1997 ‘Devolution-all-round’ settlement, have contributed to the emergence of significant numbers of Scottish and Welsh national outsiders in relation to the UK state, whilst still not fully integrating the previous Irish national outsiders. Today, the apparent inability of the UK state, with its strong conservative unionist, and growing reactionary unionist forces, to sustain a more widely supported political settlement has led considerably greater numbers to reject any notion of ‘Britishness’, particularly in Scotland.
1) The notion of ‘outsider’ and ‘toleration’ in relation to the role of the UK state in creating and maintaining Britishness
In some ways the position of black people in the UK from the late eighteenth century, addressed in Virdee’s book, represents an updated version of the toleration that appeared in the early days of capitalist development. This toleration was extended both to religious and ethnic minorities who performed a significant economic role within certain states. Such toleration was found in some city-states, e.g. Venice [4], and then in some mercantile capitalist states, e.g. the Netherlands, England, then the UK. These states produced regulations and developed practices that altered the status of those they tolerated, either for better or worse.
Continue reading “THE UK STATE AND BRITISHNESS”
Tags: 'Better Together' Campaign, 'Blatcherism', 'Butskellism', 'ethnicised outsider', 'gendered outsider', 'mere' Irish, 'national outsider', 'One Nation Labour', 'racialised outsider', 'Spirit of 45', 'Spirit of 68', 'Ulster'-British, 'Yes' campaign, 1845-9 Great Hunger, 1905 Aliens Act, 1913 Dublin Lockout, 1914 British Nationality and Status of Aliens Act, 1916 Easter Rising, 1921 Anglo-Irish Treaty, 1962 and 1968 Commonwealth Immigration Acts, 1971 Immigration Act, 1972 Bloody Sunday, 1975 Sex Discrimination Act, 1976 Race Relations Act, 1979 Scottish Devolution Act, 1981 British Nationality Act, 1981 Brixton Riots, 1981 Hunger Strikes, 1995-2001 Drumcree Riots, 1997 Good Friday Agreement, 1998 Scottish Devolution Act, 2014 and 2015 Immigration Acts, 2014 Scottish independence referendum, administrative devolution, Alliance Party, Ancient Order of Hibernians, Anti-Partition League, Author: Allan Armstrong, Belfast Agreement, Bernadette McAliskey, Blue Labour, BNP, Break of the UK and British Empire road to socialism, Brexit, British chauvinism, British racism, British road to socialism, Britishness, Catholic, City of London, civic nationalism, Clement Attlee, Commonwealth Labour Party, Comrade or Brother: A History of the British Labour Movement, Conservative Party, conservative unionism, Council of the Isles, CPI, CPNI, Crown Powers, Crown-in-Parliament, Cumann na nGaedheal, Delia Larkin, Democratic Unionist Party, Devolution-all-round, Enoch Powell, established Church, ethnic nationalism, EU, European Union, Fascism, Fianna Fail, First Irish Republic, Free Derry, Harry Diamond, Harry Midgely, Herbert Asquith, Ian Paisley, Independent Labour Party, Ireland, Irish Boundary Commission, Irish Citizen Army, Irish Free State/'26 Counties', Irish government, Irish Home Rule, Irish Labour Party, Irish Republican Army, Irish Transport and General Workers Union, Irish Unionism, Irish Volunteer Force, Irish-British, Islamophobia, Jack Beattie, James Callaghan, James Connolly, James Larkin Junior, James Sexton, Jeremy Corbyn, Jim Larkin, Joe Devlin, Kilbrandon Commission, Labour Party, Liberal Party, liberal unionism, Lloyd George, Lord Scarman, loyalists, Margaret Thatcher, Mary Davis, Michael Davitt, National Front, National Health Service, neo-conservatism, neo-fascism, New Labour, New Unionism, Norah Connolly, Northern Ireland, Northern Ireland Forum, Northern Ireland Labour Party, Northern Ireland Womens Coalition, Northern Ireland/'Six Counties', Northern irish Civil Rights Association, Offensive Behaviour Act, Orange Order, partition, Pastor Jack Glass, Peace Process, Peadar O'Donnell, Peoples Democracy, Peter Robinson, Plaid Cymru, political devolution/Home Rule, Popular Unionist Party, Protestant, Protestant Unionist Party, race riots, Rdical Independence Campaign, reactionary unionism, Republican Congress, Robert McCartney, Roddy Connolly, Roy Mason, Royal Irish Constabulary, Royal Ulster Constabulary, Sam Kyle, Satnam Virdee, Scotland, Scots-Irish, Scottish Covenant Association, Scottish-British, SDLP, Sectarianism, Sinn Fein, Sir Basil Brooke, Sir Edward Carson, SNP, social conservatism, social liberalism, Socialist Party of Ireland, The 1914 Curragh Mutiny, Thomas Johnson, toleration, Tom Johnston, Tory Right, Traditional Unionist Voice, UDA, UK Unionist Party, UKIP, Ulster Protestant League, Ulster Scots Agency, Ulster Unionists, United Irish League, US imperialism, UVF, Welsh-British, William McMullen, William Walker, Winifred Carney, Winston Churchill
