• Skip to content
  • Skip to menu

Emancipation & Liberation

Republican Communist Network, (Scotland) 

Rss 2.0

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact / Subscribe
  • Internationalism From Below
  • Privacy Policy
  • Publications

Oct 21 2017

NATIONAL LIBERATION AND BOLSHEVISM RECONSIDERED – A VIEW FROM THE BORDERLANDS

Category: Against Imperialism,Capitalism and Communism,Combined struggles for Emancipation, Liberation and National Self-Determination,For Emancipation: Struggles against Exploitation,For Liberation: Struggles against Oppression,How they are organised,Russia and ex-USSR — RCN @ 5:51 pm

In the run-up to  the centenary of the October Revolution in Russia, talks and seminars have been arranged and new books and articles have been published. Some of this work has been done to uphold old orthodoxies, but there has also been more critical work looking at the Russian Revolution in the  wider context of the 1916-21/3 International Revolutionary Wave to see if there were aspects of this period that have been neglected, which could inform today’s struggles. One of these works is the article written by Eric Blanc and published in Links International Journal of Socialist Renewal. Eric  is an activist and historian in Oakland, California.

As one reviewer of this article John Riddell explains, this article “obliges us to rethink many long-held assumptions about the revolutions of 1905 and 1917, as well as the development of Marxist approaches to national liberation, peasant struggle, permanent revolution, and the emancipation of women.”

 

NATIONAL LIBERATION AND BOLSHEVISM RECONSIDERED – A VIEW FROM THE BORDERLANDS 

Helsinki, Finland during the 1905 Revolution

The following paper analyzes the socialist debates on the national question up through 1914. I argue that an effective strategy of anti-colonial Marxism was first put forward by the borderland socialists, not the Bolsheviks. Lenin and his comrades lagged behind the non-Russian Marxists on this crucial issue well into the Civil War—and this political weakness helps explain the Bolshevik failure to build roots among dominated peoples. Consequently, the Bolsheviks were either too numerically weak and/or indifferent to national aspirations to successfully lead socialist revolutions in the borderlands, facilitating the isolation of the Russian workers’ government and the subsequent rise of Stalinism. Continue reading “NATIONAL LIBERATION AND BOLSHEVISM RECONSIDERED – A VIEW FROM THE BORDERLANDS”

Tags: 1896 Congress of Second International, 1902 Czestochowa Pogrom, 1912 Prague Congress, Alexandra Kollontai, Armenian Social Democratic Labour Organisation, Author: Eric Blanc, autonomy, Baku Commune, Bolsheviks, Clara Zetkin, Communist Manifesto, Federalism, Georgian Social Democracy, Independence, Iskra, Jewish Bund, Karl Kautsky, Karl Marx, Karl Radek, Kazimierz Kelles-Kruz, Land and Freedom, Latvian Social Democratic Labour Party, Latvian Social Democratic Union, Lenin, Leo Jogiche, Leon Trotsky, Lev Yurkevich, Lithuanian Social Democracy, Martov, Mensheviks, Mulsim Social Democratic Party/Hummet, Otto Bauer, Peoples Will, Peteris Stucka, Polish Proletariat, Polish Socialist Party, PPS-Left, Revolutionary Ukrainian Party, right of national self-determination, Roas Luxemburg, Russian Socialist Revolutionaries, Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland, Social Democratic Party of Finland, Stalin, Ukrainian Social Democratic Union/Spilka

Comments (2)



  • Pages
    • About
    • Contact / Subscribe
    • Internationalism From Below
      • Global Commune
      • Republic of Letters
      • Republican Socialist Convention
    • Privacy Policy
    • Publications
  • Categories
    • Capitalism and Communism (487)
      • How they are organised (399)
        • Russia and ex-USSR (42)
        • The EU (103)
        • The global economy (51)
        • UK state/British imperialism (254)
        • US imperialism (105)
      • How we organise (260)
        • Independent class organisations (239)
        • What is communism? (22)
      • The crisis on the Left (121)
        • SSP and SWP (44)
    • Combined struggles for Emancipation, Liberation and National Self-Determination (385)
      • Against Imperialism (152)
        • Latin America and Caribbean (11)
        • Middle East and North Africa (35)
        • Sub-Saharan Africa (4)
      • Against Unionism (300)
        • England (97)
        • Ireland (185)
        • Scotland (192)
          • Radical Independence Campaign (87)
        • The Socialist Republican Break-up of the UK (95)
        • Wales (75)
    • Elections (2)
    • For Emancipation: Struggles against Exploitation (193)
      • Environmental Degradation/Sharing Our Planet (12)
      • Other Economic Struggles (43)
      • Trade Unionism (97)
    • For Liberation: Struggles against Oppression (216)
      • Other Social Struggles (51)
      • Political Campaigns (76)
        • anti-war movement (6)
        • Brian Higgins Blacklist (3)
        • Independence Convention (1)
        • No One Is Illegal (3)
      • Women’s Liberation (31)
    • For Self-Determination: Struggles against Alienation (216)
      • Commemorations (45)
      • Cultural Celebration (66)
      • Ideology and Religion: Science and Secularism (24)
      • Our History (28)
      • Reviews (28)
    • online (2)
    • Publications (284)
      • Emancipation & Liberation (284)
        • Issue 01 (16)
        • Issue 02 (20)
        • Issue 03 (18)
        • Issue 04 (14)
        • Issue 05&06 (6)
        • Issue 07 (14)
        • Issue 08 (13)
        • Issue 11 (17)
        • Issue 12 (14)
        • Issue 13 (21)
        • Issue 14 (16)
        • Issue 15 (21)
        • Issue 16 (22)
        • Issue 17 (18)
        • Issue 18 (13)
        • Issue 19 (1)
        • Issue 20 (4)
        • Issue 21 (12)
        • Issue 22 (10)
        • Issue 23 (12)
    • Uncategorized (1)
  • Tags
    Alex Salmond Author: Allan Armstrong Author: Eric Chester Author: John McAnulty Author: Steve Freeman Brexit City of London Crown Powers David Cameron Donald Trump DUP Emancipation & Liberation England EU George Galloway Greece Ireland James Connolly Jeremy Corbyn Labour Labour Party Left Unity Party Len McCluskey NATO Northern Ireland Orange Order Radical Independence Campaign Republican Communist Network Republicanism Republican Socialist Alliance Scotland Sinn Fein SNP Socialist Democracy (Ireland) SSP Stormont SWP Theresa May Tommy Sheridan Tony Blair UKIP UNITE USA Wales Westminster
  • Books
    • An Ceathru Poili, Belfast
    • Calton Books, Glasgow
    • Connolly Books, Dublin
    • Housmans Books, London
    • Lighthouse Books, Edinburgh
  • Campaign
    • Radical Independence Campaign
    • Radical Independence Campaign Edinburgh
    • Republican Socialist Alliance
  • Media
    • Bella Caledonia
    • conter
    • Revolution
    • RS21
    • Scottish Socialist Voice
    • Socialist Democracy (Ireland)
  • Our History and Culture
    • 107 Cowgate
    • Edinburgh Peoples Festival
    • The Carrying Stream
  • Meta
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org

top

Powered by WordPress and Stardust

Created by Tommaso Baldovino